| Bailey Kerns (Northwestern) | Defeated | Jason Shope (Indian Valley) | Fall 3.51 | 
| David Stroud (Northridge) | Defeated | Dylan Christman (Bellefontaine) | Fall 0.26 | 
| Gage Braun (Graham) | Defeated | Trenton Glaze (Indian Lake) | Fall 0.55 | 
| Braden Lehman (Urbana) | Defeated | Koty Kunkle (Shawnee) | M-Dec 11-2 | 
| Tanner Smith (Graham) | Defeated | Easton Crapnell (Indian Lake) | Fall 1.29 | 
| Seth Miller (Urbana) | Defeated | Justo Boggs (Northwestern) | M-Dec 16-6 | 
| Drew Clawson (Northridge) | Defeated | Jared Nicol (Ben Logan) | Dec 6-5 | 
| Dylan Johnston (Tecumseh) | Defeated | Porfirio Gonzalez (Shawnee) | Dec 6-2 | 
| Justin Stickley (Graham) | Defeated | Mikey Kimbler (Indian Lake) | Fall 1.05 | 
| Allen Eben (Tecumseh) | Defeated | Orin Reames (Ben Logan) | Fall 0.46 | 
| Sam McGill (Northwestern) | Defeated | Tanner Myers (Shawnee) | Fall 1.21 | 
| Lance Houchin (Bellefontaine) | Defeated | Mitchell Poynter (Tippecanoe) | Dec 17-13 OT | 
| Blake Biteman (Tecumseh) | Defeated | Mitchell Moyer (Urbana) | Fall 1.04 | 
| Drew Whaley (Graham) | Defeated | Skyler Baise (Northridge) | Fall 0.49 | 
| David Hickey (Mad River) | Defeated | Jeremi Doll (Northwestern) | T-Fall 16-1 | 
| Silas Davis (Indian Lake) | Defeated | Hunter Swingley (Bellefontaine) | Fall 0.47 | 
| Mario Kastl (Graham) | Defeated | Zach Palmer (Indian Lake) | Fall 1.11 | 
| Bryan Ward (Bellefontaine) | Defeated | Austin Deel (Indian Valley) | Dec 9-8 | 
| Seth D'Allessandris (Shawnee) | Defeated | Brandon Ray (Mad River) | Fall 1.07 | 
| Langston Kitchen (Urbana) | Defeated | Brandon Castillo (Tecumseh) | Fall 0.22 | 
| Brent Moore (Graham) | Defeated | Jordan Brown (Tippecanoe) | Fall 1.40 | 
| Dakota Brown (Shawnee) | Defeated | C.J. Starr (Northwestern) | Fall 1.22 | 
| Tristan Varian (Bellefontaine) | Defeated | Jacob Bauman (Mad River) | Fall 0.44 | 
| Kurt Crockett (Indian Lake) | Defeated | Dominic Kuzujabakis (Indian Valley) | Fall 1.15 | 
| Trevor Anderson (Indian Lake) | Defeated | Derek Weiser (Ben Logan) | Fall 0.46 | 
| Ben Boggs (Northwestern) | Defeated | Matthew Huffman (Mad River) | Dec 9-3 | 
| Garrett Jordan (Graham) | Defeated | Austin Allen (Bellefontaine) | Fall 2.02 | 
| Kyle Lawson (Graham) | Defeated | Tim Sidders (Urbana) | Fall 1.28 | 
| Jack Peura (Tippecanoe) | Defeated | Andrew Aldredge (Northwestern) | Fall 0.46 | 
| Isaiah Davis (Indian Lake) | Defeated | Mitch Current (Ben Logan) | Fall 1.07 | 
| Wade Smiddy (Shawnee) | Defeated | Nate Walden (Northridge) | Fall 0.46 | 
| Brandon Henderson (Indian Lake) | Defeated | Zac Cunningham (Bellefontaine) | Fall 0.41 | 
| Forrest Hyden (Graham) | Defeated | Blake Speakman (Northwestern) | Fall 2.07 | 
| Jamal Reynolds (Northridge) | Defeated | Sam Fearing (Tippecanoe) | Fall 4.00 | 
| Ryan Sheeley (Ben Logan) | Defeated | Alec Upton (Indian Valley) | Fall 0.19 | 
| Nathan Bills (Northwestern) | Defeated | Jacob Browne (Northridge) | Fall 0.36 | 
| Jake Humphreys (Shawnee) | Defeated | Jacob Walland (Tippecanoe) | Fall 0.46 | 
| Eric Masden (Tecumseh) | Defeated | Mason Diener (Indian Lake) | Dec 6-4 | 
| Brody Grimm (Graham) | Defeated | Ryan Riggs (Indian Valley) | FF | 
| Jacob Angles (Urbana) | Defeated | David Dengliner (Indian Valley) | Fall 3.37 | 
| Phillip Craig (Bellefontaine) | Defeated | Nate Warniment (Indian Lake) | Dec 7-5 | 
| Jesse Enke (Graham) | Defeated | Caleb Staigers (Northridge) | Fall 0.55 | 
| Zach Long (Indian Lake) | Defeated | Landon Sopher (Bellefontaine) | Fall 2.35 | 
| Trenton Butterfield (Indian Lake) | Defeated | William Hall (Shawnee) | Fall 2.30 | 
| Grant Carlson (Tippecanoe) | Defeated | Jordan Bowen (Northridge) | Fall 1.26 | 
| Cole Craig (Ben Logan) | Defeated | Bayley Orahood (Bellefontaine) | Fall 0.45 | 
| Blake Treen (Bellefontaine) | Defeated | Ryan Bolton (Tippecanoe) | Fall 1.00 | 
| Steven Majors (Indian Lake) | Defeated | Kaylan Shock (Indian Valley) | Fall 1.09 | 
| Keith Gale (Urbana) | Defeated | Brandon Hayes (Graham) | Fall 0.23 |